Sample rubrics for laboratory output
Creating a rubric takes time and requires thought and experimentation. Here you can see the steps used to create two kinds of rubric: one for problems in a physics exam for a small, upper-division physics course, and another for an essay assignment in a large, lower-division sociology course. In STEM disciplines science, technology, engineering, and mathematicsassignments tend to be analytical and problem-based.
Often holistic rubrics are the most efficient, consistent, and fair way to grade a problem set. When starting to grade a problem, it is important to think about the relevant conceptual ingredients in the solution.
Then look at a sample of student work to get a feel for student mistakes. Decide what rubric you will use e. Finally, check the stacks for consistency and mark the scores. The following is a sample homework problem from a UC Berkeley Physics Department undergraduate course in quantum mechanics. Understand Compton scattering and apply the concepts in a calculation.
The discovery of Compton scattering was important in the early development of Quantum Mechanics because it illustrates the quantum nature of light and cannot be correctly described using classical electromagnetism. A note on analytic rubrics: If you decide you feel more comfortable grading with an analytic rubric, you can assign a point value to each concept.
The drawback to this method is that it can sometimes unfairly penalize a student who has a good understanding of the problem but makes a lot of minor errors. Also, one must assign a point-value to every type of error made by your students, and the variety of mistakes can be staggering. Because the analytic method tends to have many more parts, the method can take quite a bit more time to apply. In the end, your analytic rubric should give results that agree with the common-sense assessment of how well the student understood the problem.
This sense is well captured by the holistic method. It prof.ssa mangiò r. – italiano, storia, geografia – istituto also be reasonable to have stricter standards for homework problems.
Individual Activity Rubric
An introductory-level, large-lecture course is a difficult setting for managing a student research assignment. With the assistance of an instructional support team that included a GSI teaching consultant certified hemp seed companies a UC Berkeley librarian [b]sociology lecturer Mary Kelsey developed the following assignment:.
This was a lengthy and complex assignment worth a substantial portion of the course grade. For these reasons Dr. Kelsey and the instructional team gave a lot of forethought to crafting a detailed grading rubric. For this assignment, the instructional team decided to grade each trait individually because there seemed to be too many independent variables to grade holistically. They could have used a five-point scale, a three-point scale, or a descriptive analytic scale.
The choice depended on the complexity of the assignment and the kind of information they wanted to convey to students about their work. Below are three of the analytic rubrics they considered for the Argument trait and a holistic rubric for all the traits together.Spreadsheet Database Form. Teacher's Form for Group Evaluation.
Team Evaluation Form. You do not need to select a plan or take a free trial in order to use your credits. Simply search for and open the item that you want. A counter will appear when you view an individual item. Note: the counter will only appear on premium resources, not resources that were already free. This customizable rubric will help you to assess students' comprehension and performance for individual activities.
The ten-point scale makes it easy to convert to a percentile score or a letter grade. Tailor the PDF to your needs by typing in the highlighted fields before printing. Back to School. Teaching Strategies:. New Teacher Resources. Classroom Management. Manage My Favorites. Excerpted from. Buy the Book. Related Resources. Tailor the PDF to your needs Read more. This spreadsheet database form can be used for a variety This is an excellent way to encourage students toRubrics simplify the process of assessing and grading student work.
They make an educator's life easier by allowing them to quickly determine whether a student has grasped a concept and which areas of their work exceed, meet, or fall short of expectations. Rubrics are an irreplaceable tool to have but take time to make. Learn the features of a basic rubric and use the following samples for a great grading instrument in no time. Performance descriptors are used to evaluate a student's work within these classifications. Read to find out more about the critical features of a rubric.
The action verbs and phrases used to describe a task or performance are important. The description must detail the features of a successful performance—what each student should be able to do, show, or otherwise apply following a lesson or unit do not use negative language that tells what a student is not doing.
The rest of the rubric determines whether this expectation has been met. The description should be as specific and detailed as possible to leave no room for uncertainty when analyzing student work. A teacher should be able to hold a student's work against this description and immediately determine how effective their performance was.
Example: The student interprets the purpose of an informational text by making connections between its various text features captions, diagrams, subheadings, etc. The criteria of a rubric qualify every aspect of student work.
Criteria may be found in the form of individual skills or abilities associated with overall performance, features of the work, dimensions of student thinking that went into the task, or specific objectives that a student must meet within a larger goal. You might find that a student's work satisfies or even goes beyond some criteria while only approaching others. This is normal!
All students learn differently and some concepts make sense to them sooner than others. Example: Within the goal of interpreting an informational text using its text features, a student must be able to name text features, explain reasons for using text features, locate the main ideas of the text, and answer questions about the text. A successful student fully meets each of these criteria. Example: The criteria for evaluating a student's oral presentation are eye contact, pacing, volume, content, and preparedness.
Qualifiers quantify success by telling the extent to which a student meets each expectation. Four-point scales like the one described below are common because they clearly show the levels of accomplishment but the number of gradations is up to your discretion. Whatever you choose, be as specific as possible about the characteristics of performance at every degree. The qualifiers assigned to a student's work are significant because they ultimately determine the overall score.
Share Flipboard Email.
'+$(".sectionnavigation .ui-widget-header h1").text()+'
Janelle Cox. Education Expert.
Janelle Cox, M. Updated October 22, A basic rubric template must have the following features. A description of the task or performance being evaluated Criteria that divide student work into categories A rating scale with three or more qualifiers that tell the degree to which expectations are met. Great action verbs to try include:. The following list gives examples of precise language that might be used to describe scores. Description of the task the rubric is designed to evaluate.Teacher's Form for Group Evaluation.
Individual Activity Rubric. Spreadsheet Database Form. Team Evaluation Form. You do not need to select a plan or take a free trial in order to use your credits. Simply search for and open the item that you want. A counter will appear when you view an individual item. Note: the counter will only appear on premium resources, not resources that were already free. Evaluate students' participation and performance in a group activity with this customizable rubric.
Tailor the PDF to your needs by typing in the highlighted fields before printing. This rubric can be used for a variety of group activities, including language arts, social studies presentations, science projects, and others. Back to School. Graphic Organizers. Teaching Strategies:.Grade Using a Rubric in the Original Course View
Group Work. New Teacher Resources. Classroom Management. Manage My Favorites. Excerpted from. Buy the Book. Related Resources. This is an excellent way to encourage students to Read more. This printable provides an excellent place to inform The ten-point This spreadsheet database form can be used for a variety Use this resource as an answer sheet for Tailor the PDF to your teaching needs by FEN Learning is part of Sandbox Networks, a millennial learning company, reaching hundreds of millions of people across the globe.Site Menu expand.
Messages From Our Office. The following are sample program learning outcomes and rubrics to provide some guidance in the development of assessment standards.
Grading Rubrics: Examples of Rubric Creation
These are merely examples and can be modified to fit the needs of your program. The outcomes and measurements MUST be relevant and meaningful to your program, providing information that will be useful in continuing quality improvement. Examples of Program Learning Outcomes Some learning outcomes will require a rubric with perimeters for achievement, some will be percentage achievement, and still others may be designed as milestones completed with time or percentage as unit measured.
Ideally, your assessments will combine direct and indirect measures. The following are examples of some assessment ideas which are fairly typical of graduate assessment. Depending on your program, what works for you will vary, but most programs should address the following assessment themes:.
Demonstrate, through service, the value of their discipline to the academy and community at large. Demonstrate a mastery of skills and knowledge at a level required for college and university undergraduate teaching in their discipline and assessment of student learning.
Critical Thinking Analyze and evaluate the literature relevant to their area of study. Critically apply theories, methodologies, and knowledge to address fundamental questions in their primary area of study. Pursue research of significance in the discipline or an interdisciplinary or creative project. Applications Apply research theories, methodologies, and disciplinary knowledge to address fundamental questions in their primary area of study. Produce and defend an original significant contribution to knowledge Develop professional curriculum vitae with required skills to secure a profession position appropriate to their degree.
Be able to conduct scholarly activities in an ethical manner. Understand ethical issues and responsibilities especially in matters related to professionalism and if applicable in matters related the laboratory setting and in writing and publishing scientific papers.
The assessment of program-level learning outcomes should be formative, providing information on students as they work toward achieving required outcomes, and summative, determining satisfactory progress toward degree completion. Note: Rubrics must not be used to asses or evaluate individual students, and should not inform the decision regarding whether a student passes a defense or course.
The data should be aggregated for all students in the program over a two-year period in order to assess the success of the program in meeting its program learning outcomes. Use of Rubrics Rubrics are a more precise means of establishing student performance. Depending on the assessment measures for your program learning outcomes, they can be invaluable in seeing trends in the attainment of student achievement.
The following are rubrics are from various sources, and they are certainly not the limit your option.
Levels can be descriptive as abovenumericalor a combination of both. Rubric for the Assessment of Subject Content Knowledge. The main question and subsidiary, embedded or implicit aspects of a question are identified and clearly stated. Evidence is used but not carefully examined; source s of evidence are not questioned for accuracy, precision, relevance and completeness; facts and opinions are stated but not clearly distinguished from value judgments.
Evidence is identified and carefully examined for accuracy, precision, relevance, and completeness; facts and opinions are stated and clearly distinguished; combines facts and ideas to create new knowledge that is comprehensive and significant. Combines few facts and ideas; needs more development; conclusions, implications; consequences are not provided.
Accurately identifies conclusions, implications, and consequences with a brief evaluative summary; uses perspectives and insights to explain relationships; states own position on the question.From Stevens, D. Introduction to Rubrics: An assessment tool to save grading time, convey effective feedback and promote student learning. Sterling, VA: Stylus Publishing; pp. Task description: Conduct the assigned lab using the procedures and methods described below.
Turn in your laboratory report at the beginning of the next class period. All materials needed are present and entered on the lab report.
Sample Learning Outcomes and Rubrics
The materials are appropriate for the procedure. The student is not wasteful of the materials. All materials needed are present, but not all are entered on the lab report, or some materials are absent and must be obtained during the procedure. All materials needed are not present and are not entered on the lab report.
The materials are not all appropriate for the procedure or there are some major omissions. The procedure is well designed and allows control of all variables selected. All stages of the procedure are entered on the lab report. The procedure could be more efficiently designed, but it allows control of all variables selected. Most stages of the procedure are entered on the lab report. The procedure does not allow control of all variables selected.
Many stages of the procedure are not entered on the lab report. While conducting the procedure, the student is tidy, respectful of others, mindful of safety, and leaves the area clean. While conducting the procedure, the student is mostly tidy, sometimes respectful of others, sometimes mindful of safety, and leaves the area clean only after being reminded. While conducting the procedure, the student is untidy, not respectful of others, not mindful of safety, and leaves the area messy even after being reminded.
Research question and hypothesis are stated clearly, and the relationship between the two is clear. The variables are selected. Research question and hypothesis are stated, but one or both are not as clear as they might be, or the relationship between the two is unclear. Research question and hypothesis are not stated clearly, and the relationship between the two is unclear or absent. The variables are not selected. Raw data, including units, are recorded in a way that is appropriate and clear.
The title of the data table is included. Raw data, including units, are recorded although not as clearly or appropriately as they might be.
Raw data, including units, are not recorded in a way that is appropriate and clear. The title of the data table is not included. Data are presented in ways charts, tables, graphs that best facilitate understanding and interpretation.
Error analysis is included. Data are presented in ways charts, tables, graphs that can be understood and interpreted, although not as clearly as they might be. Data are presented in ways charts, tables, graphs that are very unclear.Part 1. What is a rubric? Part 2. Why use a rubric? Part 3. What are the parts of a rubric? Part 4. Developing a rubric Part 5. Sample rubrics Part 6. Scoring rubric group orientation and calibration Part 7. Suggestions for Using Rubrics in Courses Part 8.
Tips for developing a rubric. A rubric is an assessment tool often shaped like a matrix, which describes levels of achievement in a specific area of performance, understanding, or behavior. Analytic Rubric : An analytic rubric specifies at least two characteristics to be assessed at each performance level and provides a separate score for each characteristic e. The English Department collected essays from students in all sections of English A random sample of essays was selected.
A team of faculty members evaluated the essays by applying an analytic scoring rubric. At the beginning of each semester, instructors met and discussed sample lab reports.
Each of those reports are then scored by a Biology professor. The score given by the course instructor is compared to the score given by the Biology professor. Step 2: Identify the characteristics to be rated rows.
Tip: Faculty members often find it useful to establish the minimum score needed for the student work to be deemed passable. Monica has posted materials from standard setting workshops, one offered on campus and the other at a national conference includes speaker notes with the presentation slides. If assessment study results fall short, action will need to be taken.
Important: When developing a rubric for program assessment, enlist the help of colleagues. Rubrics promote shared expectations and consistent grading practices which benefit faculty members and students in the program.
Rubrics are in our Rubric Bank and more are available at the Assessment Office hard copy. When using a rubric for program assessment purposes, faculty members apply the rubric to pieces of student work e. To produce dependable scores, each faculty member needs to interpret the rubric in the same way. Below are directions for an assessment coordinator carrying out this process. Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email.